Eleven Annual Days. Eleven Generic Gifts. And Then Someone Finally Got It Right.
By Aarthy Balachandran | Founder, The Knots Studio
I want to tell you about a conversation I almost did not
have.
It was a Tuesday morning, about six weeks before their
company's Annual Day celebration, and an HR head from a well-established
manufacturing company in Bengaluru had reached out to us for a quote on gifting
for approximately three hundred and fifty employees.
Annual Day, for those who have organised one, is not a small
matter in Indian corporate culture. It is the moment when an organisation steps
back from the relentless pace of the working year and says, collectively and
publicly, thank you for everything this year has meant. The speeches, the
awards, the performances, the dinner, and the gift that every employee takes
home at the end of the evening.
That gift is the last impression of the entire event. It is
what travels home with every person in the room. It is what sits on their
kitchen counter or their work desk or their bedroom table in the days and weeks
that follow. And it is what they remember when they think about how the company
made them feel on that particular evening.
The initial brief was simple. Something appropriate for the
occasion. Something within budget. Something that would go out on time and
reflect well on the organisation at their most important internal event of the
year.
I sent across our proposal. And then came the reply that I
have received, in various forms, more times than I can count.
"Aarthy, the quote looks good but we found something
similar for a bit less from another vendor. Can you match that price?"
I sat with that message for a few minutes before I
responded. Not because the answer was complicated. But because I wanted to make
sure that when I replied I was genuinely trying to help her rather than simply
defending our pricing.
And what followed was one of the most honest and ultimately
most valuable conversations I have had in the history of building The Knots
Studio.
The Easy Answer and Why I Did Not Give It
The easy answer in that situation is to say no, explain
briefly that our quality justifies our pricing, wish the client well, and move
on.
The slightly less easy but more common answer is to
negotiate. To find some middle ground that keeps the business while quietly
compromising on something that the client may or may not notice until it is too
late.
I did neither.
Instead I asked if she had thirty minutes for a proper
meeting. Not a quick call. A meeting. Because what I wanted to share with her
was not something that could be done justice in five minutes of back and forth,
and I genuinely felt that if she understood what she was actually comparing she
would be in a much better position to make a decision that served her organisation
and her employees well.
She agreed. And we sat down together, properly, with enough
time to have the conversation that the situation deserved.
The First Thing I Asked Her
The first question I asked was not about the other vendor or
their pricing. It was about her employees and about Annual Day itself.
I asked her to tell me about the last time her company had
celebrated Annual Day. What had the gift been? How had it been received? What
was the energy in the room when it was distributed and what was the
conversation among employees in the days that followed?
She thought about it for a moment.
She said the gifts the previous year had been perfectly
fine. A standard hamper that was put together for the occasion. Employees had
said thank you. The event itself had been enjoyable. But when she thought about
it honestly, the gift had not really added to the memory of the evening in any
meaningful way. It had been there and then it had been taken home and that was
essentially all she could say about it.
I asked whether any employee had come back to her in the
weeks after Annual Day specifically because of the gift. Whether anyone had
mentioned it in a way that suggested it had meant something to them personally
rather than simply being a nice thing to receive.
She was honest. No, not really.
I told her that was not unusual. And I told her it was
exactly what I wanted to help her change this year, if she was willing to think
about it differently for thirty minutes.
What a Slightly Cheaper Gift Actually Costs
I want to be direct about something here because I think the
gifting industry in India does a poor job of having this conversation honestly.
When a client receives a quote that is a bit less than
another, the natural assumption is that the cheaper vendor has found a more
efficient way to produce the same outcome. Better supplier relationships
perhaps. More streamlined operations. Simply lower margins.
Sometimes that is true. But more often the difference in
price reflects a difference in what is actually being delivered. And that
difference is almost always invisible in a catalogue or a quote. It only
becomes visible when the gifts arrive.
The materials that looked premium in a photograph but feel
ordinary in the hand. The packaging that photographs well but shows its
limitations when someone actually opens it. The customisation that was
described as precise but arrives with colours that do not quite match the brand
identity. The products that have been selected because they photograph well
rather than because they will be genuinely valued and used by the people
receiving them.
None of these things are visible at the point of comparison.
They surface after the commitment has been made and the gifts have been
distributed. And by then three hundred and fifty employees have taken their
Annual Day gift home. And the impression that gift makes, or fails to make, is
the impression that stays.
I shared this with her not as a criticism of the other
vendor. I genuinely do not know what another vendor is or is not doing. I
shared it because it is the honest context that I would want someone to provide
me if I were making this decision for my own organisation.
The Conversation About Personalisation and What It
Actually Means
This is where the meeting took a turn that I had not entirely
anticipated. But it was the turn that mattered most.
I asked her to describe the other vendor's proposed hamper
contents to me. Not the price or the packaging, just the products. What was
actually inside.
She listed them. And as she listed them I could see on her
face that she was hearing them slightly differently than she had when she first
reviewed the quote. Because she was hearing them now in the context of a
conversation about what her employees actually needed and valued rather than in
the context of a price comparison.
The products were generic. Entirely competent, entirely
inoffensive, and entirely disconnected from anything specific about her
workforce or her company culture or the particular significance of this year's
Annual Day.
I asked her about her team. What was the age profile? What
kinds of roles did they work in? Were they predominantly office based or did
many of them spend significant time on the factory floor or in the field? What
were the lifestyle preferences and daily routines of her workforce that a truly
thoughtful hamper needed to account for rather than defaulting to the standard
set of items that every gifting catalogue defaults to? About the cultural
diversity of her team and what it meant to choose products that felt inclusive
and considered for everyone in the room rather than simply safe and generic?
She had answers to most of these questions because she is a
good HR professional who knows her organisation. And as she answered we began
to build something together that looked quite different from either of the two
quotes she had been comparing.
The hamper we developed together for her Annual Day had
contents that were selected specifically for her workforce. Products that would
be genuinely useful and valued in the daily lives of people who worked the
hours they worked and lived the way they lived. Lifestyle considerations built
thoughtfully into every product choice. A selection that honoured the real
lives of her team rather than defaulting to the safest possible middle ground.
The other vendor's hamper could have gone to any company's
Annual Day and been entirely appropriate. Our hamper was designed for her
company, for her people, for this particular Annual Day.
And that distinction matters more than most people realise
when they are sitting down to compare gifting proposals.
The Conversation About What She Was Actually Buying
At some point in that meeting I said something that I think
shifted the entire conversation.
I said that when she was comparing the two proposals, she
was not actually comparing the cost of three hundred and fifty hampers. She was
comparing the cost of three hundred and fifty moments.
Moments when an employee takes their Annual Day gift home
and the event follows them there. When they open it in front of their family
and their family sees what the company thought to give them. When they find a
place for it in their daily life or discover that it does not quite fit there.
When they think, in the days that follow the event, about whether the
organisation they work for sees them clearly or sees them as an interchangeable
unit of workforce.
Annual Day is the one moment in the corporate calendar that
is explicitly about celebrating people. Not a project. Not a result. Not a
quarter. The people themselves. The year of their work and their commitment and
their presence in the organisation.
What the gift says on that particular evening is therefore
not background noise. It is the loudest quiet signal the organisation sends all
year.
Research consistently and clearly shows that employees who
feel genuinely recognised and valued are significantly more engaged, more
productive, and substantially more likely to stay with their organisation. The
Gallup Organisation has documented this relationship extensively over decades
of research across thousands of organisations globally. Employee recognition,
when it feels authentic and thoughtful, drives outcomes that no recruitment
budget or retention programme can replicate.
An Annual Day gift that feels personal and considered is not
a luxury. It is an investment in the very things that HR heads and CHROs spend
enormous energy trying to build. Loyalty. Engagement. A sense of genuine
belonging.
She was quiet for a moment after I said this. And then she
said she had never thought about it quite that way before. That she had always
thought of the gift as the last item on the Annual Day planning checklist
rather than as an integral part of what the evening was communicating to her
employees.
I understood that completely. Because it is how most
organisations think about gifting until they experience what happens when it is
done with genuine intention.
What We Actually Proposed and Why It Worked
Once the conversation had shifted from a price comparison to
a genuine discussion about what she wanted her employees to feel on Annual Day,
something changed between us.
She became curious about what was actually possible rather
than focused on justifying a number. Her questions changed completely. She
stopped asking whether we could match a price and started asking what the right
gift for her organisation would actually look like and what it would require to
create it.
We talked about the composition of her workforce in detail.
About the products that would be genuinely valued and used by people doing the
work they do and living the lives they live outside the office. About the
lifestyle preferences and daily routines of her team that a truly thoughtful
hamper needed to account for rather than defaulting to the standard set of
items that every gifting catalogue defaults to. About the cultural diversity of
her team and what it meant to choose products that felt inclusive and
considered for everyone in the room rather than simply safe and generic. About
the packaging and how the experience of opening the gift would feel at the end
of an evening that was supposed to celebrate the people in the room.
We talked about the difference between a hamper that was
appropriate for the occasion and one that was genuinely designed for the
people.
And by the end of the meeting we had built something that
was genuinely distinct from both the original proposal and the cheaper
alternative. Not because we had added expensive items for the sake of it but
because we had made deliberate choices about what belonged in a gift for her
specific workforce at this specific moment in their company's story.
The final investment was meaningfully less different from
the cheaper quote than she had initially expected. Because when we focused on
building the right gift rather than defending a price point, we found ways to
create something significantly more purposeful without unnecessary cost.
She placed the order.
What Happened at Annual Day
She called me about ten days after the event.
I could tell from the first moment of the conversation that
something significant had happened.
She told me the response from employees had been completely
unlike anything she had experienced in her years of organising Annual Day.
People had approached her specifically during the event to comment on the gift
before they had even left the venue. A department head had sent her a message
the following morning saying that two members of his team who had been quietly
considering leaving the organisation had each told him independently that the
evening had reminded them why they joined in the first place.
One employee, who had attended eleven Annual Days with the
company, had come to her office two days after the event. He had worked in the
same role for most of those eleven years. He sat down across from her and told
her that this was the first Annual Day where the gift had made him feel like
the company had actually thought about the people in the room rather than
simply fulfilling an obligation to mark the occasion.
Eleven years. Eleven Annual Days. And it was only in the
eleventh year, when someone finally made the decision to invest properly in the
value of the moment rather than the lowest possible cost of filling a gift bag,
that an employee felt genuinely seen and considered on the night that was supposed
to be about celebrating him.
She had to pause in the middle of telling me this. It had
clearly moved her when she heard it. And it moved me too when she shared it.
That is what thoughtful gifting actually does. Not when it
is a tiebreaker between similar offers. But when someone genuinely decides that
it deserves the same care and intention that goes into every other part of a
celebration.
What She Has Become to The Knots Studio
That client is now one of our most valued and
longest-standing partners.
In the time since that first Annual Day order she has worked
with us on onboarding kits for every new batch of joiners her organisation
brings in. On recognition gifts for work anniversaries and individual
milestones. On a client appreciation programme for their key external partners.
And on the gifting for every Annual Day since that first one.
She refers us to other HR heads in her network with a
specificity that I find genuinely meaningful. She does not simply say The Knots
Studio are good at gifting. She says they will change how you think about what
gifting is for.
And every time I speak with her I am grateful that I asked
for thirty minutes rather than accepting that a price comparison had already
decided the conversation.
What This Means for You
If you are an HR head or Admin leader who is currently
comparing gifting proposals and trying to work out where the value lies, I want
to offer you the same honest perspective I offered her in that meeting.
Price comparison is a natural and reasonable starting point.
But it is only a useful tool if what is being compared is actually comparable.
And in corporate gifting, two proposals that appear to be for the same thing
are very often proposals for quite different experiences.
The difference does not show in the quote. It shows in the
sourcing. The quality. The thoughtfulness of the contents and how well they
reflect the actual people receiving them. The care taken with the packaging and
the finishing. The reliability of delivery. The transparency of the vendor when
something needs to be discussed honestly.
And most importantly it shows in the response of the people
who receive the gift.
The question worth asking before making a decision based on
price alone is the question I asked that HR head at the beginning of our
meeting.
What do you want your employees to feel when they receive
this gift and take it home from your Annual Day?
Because that answer is what should be driving your gifting
decision. Not the cost of the hamper. The value of the moment. The impression that
stays. The feeling that an employee carries with them when they think about the
organisation they chose to work for.
That feeling is what corporate gifting is actually for. And
it is worth investing in properly.
A Final Thought
I started The Knots Studio because I believed that gifting
in India deserved far more intention and care than it typically receives. As a
woman entrepreneur who spent sixteen years working in large organisations and
sat on the other side of vendor relationships in multiple companies, I
experienced firsthand what it felt like when gifting was done with genuine
thought and what it felt like when it was simply a box to tick.
The difference between those two experiences is not subtle.
And it is not primarily a question of money.
It is a question of someone deciding that the people on the
receiving end of a gift deserve to feel that someone thought carefully about
them. And then making every decision in the gifting process in service of that
commitment.
That is what we try to bring to every single order at The
Knots Studio. Whether it is fifty onboarding kits for a growing startup or five
hundred hampers for a large corporate celebration. The same commitment to
making the person who receives the gift feel that they were seen and considered.
We would genuinely love to bring that to your organisation
and your next important occasion.
📩 aarthy@theknotsstudio.com
📸
instagram.com/theknotsstudio
💼
linkedin.com/company/the-knots-studio
And a question for everyone reading this:
Think about the most memorable gift you have ever received
at a corporate event or celebration. What made it stand out in a way that the
others did not? Share it in the comments below. Because understanding what
genuinely moves people is how all of us get better at creating those moments
for the people who work with us.
#CorporateGifting #TheKnotsStudio #AnnualDay #HRLeaders
#CHRO #AdminLeaders #EmployeeEngagement #GiftingThatMatters
#PersonalisedGifting #WomenEntrepreneur #BengaluruBusiness #Founders
#PeopleAndCulture #BespokeCorporateGifting #TalentRetention #EmployeeRecognition
#GiftingStrategy #HRCommunity #ValueOverPrice #ClientStory
Comments
Post a Comment